Home European Union Poland Should Ask What the EU Budget Can Do for Europe. So...

Poland Should Ask What the EU Budget Can Do for Europe. So Should Others

Piotr Serafin (European Commissioner for Budget, Anti-Fraud and Public Administration)

By Marek Tatala, an economist and president of the Polish think tank Economic Freedom Foundation

National governments want to get as much as possible from the EU budget, but who is asking what Europe itself gets in return? As negotiations over the next long-term budget intensify, this question matters far more than the size of any national allocation.

The European Commission wants more spending on defence, security, competitiveness and innovation. Many member states want to protect traditional funding for agriculture and cohesion, while others demand fiscal restraint. Responding to the latter, the Irish Presidency has proposed cutting the Commission’s spending plans by around 8%, to €1.62 trillion in 2025 prices.

Yet the fundamental question remains: does Europe need a bigger budget, or does it need to spend its money better?

Poland needs a different perspective

Poland is among the countries advocating a larger EU budget. After two decades as one of the largest beneficiaries of EU funds, more spending in Brussels is widely associated with more money for Polish infrastructure, agriculture and public investment. As a Polish economist, I find myself in a minority. I believe a smaller EU budget could be better for Poland and Europe.

First, the greatest economic benefits of European integration have come not from subsidies, but from the Single Market, trade, competition and investment. Research on Poland suggests that the economic benefits of the Single Market have been at least five times greater than those of EU funds.

Second, Poland will eventually become a net contributor to the EU budget. We should welcome that moment as a sign of growing prosperity. It is time to ask less often, “How much will Poland get from the EU budget?” and instead ask a question that should matter across Europe: “What will Europe gain from the EU budget?”

Negotiations should not resemble a competition over who brings home the largest cheque. Cross-border transport links, energy networks and joint research infrastructure can deliver benefits that individual countries cannot achieve alone. Another local investment or sectoral subsidy is a different matter.

This is why EPICENTER’s Alternative EU Budget deserves attention. It proposes an even smaller framework of approximately €1.54 trillion in 2025 prices, based on a simple principle: EU money should finance activities that deliver genuine European added value and cannot be carried out as effectively by member states. That requires difficult choices. New priorities cannot simply be added to old ones indefinitely. If everything is a priority, nothing is.

More spending means finding more revenue

Someone must finance a larger EU budget. The Commission has proposed several new own resources, including those linked to the Emissions Trading System (ETS), the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), contributions from large companies (CORE) and tobacco excise duties (TEDOR).

These are presented as ways to finance common priorities while limiting pressure on national budgets. But there is no such thing as free EU money. Some mechanisms would redirect revenues currently available to member states. This matters particularly for Poland, which faces one of the EU’s largest fiscal deficits and must consolidate its public finances. Other instruments would impose costs on businesses and consumers.

The growing interest in health-related taxes is particularly revealing. In early November, I attended a Brussels discussion organised by the Wilfried Martens Centre for European Studies and EPICENTER on health taxes as potential EU revenue sources. Beyond the proposed TEDOR, the discussion covered taxes on foods considered unhealthy. Ideas to finance EU spending through alcohol excise duties have also surfaced.

These proposals come wrapped in public health arguments. Some may have legitimate health objectives, but their growing appeal also reflects fiscal pressures. There is an obvious contradiction: if taxes successfully discourage harmful consumption, they may also undermine their own revenue base. That raises questions about relying on them to finance permanent expenditure.

Poorly designed excise duties and so-called sin taxes can also encourage illicit trade and disproportionately burden lower-income consumers. Using public health policy as a fiscal tool requires a comprehensive assessment of costs, benefits and unintended consequences.

A more European budget, not a larger one

If member states genuinely want to spend more at the EU level, there is a more transparent option: openly discuss higher contributions based on their economic capacity, rather than introduce an expanding collection of sectoral levies.

But perhaps no additional revenue is needed at all. Governments should first reconsider existing spending, identify genuine priorities and ask which objectives the EU can achieve more effectively than member states acting individually.

Europe needs better defence cooperation, stronger external borders, integrated energy networks and a more competitive Single Market. Many of these objectives require fewer regulatory barriers and more private investment rather than additional taxpayers’ money.

For Poland, growing wealth should mean becoming more demanding about the quality of European expenditure. That matters more than the size of our national allocation.

The next EU budget should not be judged by how much each member state receives or how much Brussels manages to raise. It should be judged by how effectively it addresses Europe’s real priorities. The goal should be more European value, not more European spending.

 

Disclaimer: www.BrusselsReport.eu will under no circumstance be held legally responsible or liable for the content of any article appearing on the website, as only the author of an article is legally responsible for that, also in accordance with the terms of use.