Home European Union When trust is scarcer than oil

When trust is scarcer than oil

By Daniele Nahum, a City Councillor in the Italian city of Milan

Some Gulf summits were cancelled, others postponed, and one ran at full capacity. Behind the gap lies a question Europe should be asking first: what makes a city bankable once the insurers walk away?

On 2 November, Meg O’Neill took her seat on the opening chief executives’ panel at ADIPEC in Abu Dhabi, beside RWE’s Markus Krebber, to discuss how energy systems absorb shocks. Three weeks earlier, BP had sent her apologies to the World Petroleum Council’s congress in Riyadh. A Houthi missile had struck King Khalid International Airport, killing 13 people and injuring more than 300. Nobody in the Abu Dhabi hall needed the irony spelt out.

That episode is the Gulf’s autumn in miniature. Since September, Yemen’s Houthis have been firing missiles and drones at Saudi Arabia most days, and operations at the capital’s main airport were suspended. The chief executives of ExxonMobil, Shell and TotalEnergies also stayed away from the petroleum congress. Then the EU and the Gulf Cooperation Council shelved the summit they had planned for Riyadh on 24 October.

The Future Investment Initiative, the kingdom’s shop window for global capital, went next. Its tenth edition has been pushed back to 2027. The organisers’ statement made no mention of security; coming days after the airport strikes, it hardly needed to. A UN data forum, an exhibition tennis tournament and a round of the World Rally Championship have since dropped off the calendar as well.

A short flight away, ADIPEC wound up on 5 November after what its organisers describe as their biggest show yet. There were 2,260 exhibitors and 16 halls with no floor space to spare; the opening ceremony had to move to another building to make room. More than 40 ministers attended, and the organisers expected 239,000 visitors from over 170 countries.

The lazy reading is that one capital is up and another is down. That is half the story at best. To understand November, go back to March.

The spring reckoning

By the time a ceasefire took hold on 8 April, Iran had fired more than 2,800 missiles and drones at the UAE, more than at any other country. In those weeks it was Dubai’s halls that stood empty. Middle East Energy and Arabian Travel Market were postponed, and the TOKEN2049 crypto conference was put off until next spring.

Nobody in Abu Dhabi claims a miracle. Opening ADIPEC, ADNOC’s chief executive, Sultan Al Jaber, was blunt: “We did not write our resilience playbook during this disruption.” It had been written years before, he said. It had not made the company immune, only ready.

That is the heart of it. Every economy takes hits; what separates them is how soon they can sign contracts again. The decisions that shorten that wait rarely make headlines. They include layered air defences, a crude pipeline to Fujairah that has bypassed Hormuz since 2012, and a central bank that pumped liquidity into the system in the first days of the war. In July the IMF, less pessimistic than most forecasters, judged the UAE’s buffers to be holding and pencilled in a budget surplus for this year, even as output slips.

When the underwriters walk away

Every conference is a wager that thousands of people will arrive safely and leave with signed contracts. In normal times the insurers share that wager. This year they have all but withdrawn from war cover for Gulf events. Brokers at Marsh say one insurer, two at a stretch, will still look at it, usually a week before the doors open. Capacity has shrunk from about $1bn to $200m, and premiums are up at least twentyfold.

With no underwriter to lean on, the host’s reputation is the only guarantee left. That is what Abu Dhabi put on the table last week, and the deals done on the sidelines priced it in. ADNOC took a final investment decision on Ruwais Diyab, an unconventional gas development, and agreed to supply TotalEnergies with up to 1.6m tonnes of LNG over five years, starting this year. Nobody signs a five-year contract in a place they expect to close.

One market, several doors

None of this is cause for schadenfreude in any Gulf capital. Saudi Arabia is the target of attacks condemned from Ottawa to Tokyo, and every strike on it draws down the whole region’s credit. Foreign investors have never really seen the Gulf as a string of separate states. To them it is one market with several doors, and the competition between those doors has served them well.

This year has turned that redundancy from a convenience into a requirement. Every hub in the region has had its turn under fire. A region with more than one capable host can take a blow in one city and keep doing business in another. That is the Gulf’s real safety net, and it is worth more than any single city.

Europe’s arithmetic

Europe has more riding on this than it tends to admit. It enters winter with gas storage around 75 per cent full, below last year’s level, and benchmark prices hovering near €100 a megawatt-hour. It needs long-term contracts, and counterparties it can trust to honour them. ADNOC and its sister companies already have more than €20bn invested in German energy and industry. Talks on an EU-UAE free trade agreement have been through seven rounds, and both sides want them finished this year.

Three conclusions follow for Brussels. Reschedule the EU-GCC summit in Riyadh as soon as security allows; standing by a partner under fire is not a courtesy. Treat the UAE agreement as energy security first and trade second, and get it signed. And European companies should stop treating the Gulf’s conference calendar as a sideshow. It is where long-term contracts are made, and this year it is the most honest gauge of which parts of the region remain investable in wartime.

The executives who could not reach Riyadh in October did not walk away from the Gulf. Their planes simply landed somewhere else, and the compass that used to point to Riyadh now points to Abu Dhabi. A Europe looking for warmth this winter knows which door was left open.

 

Disclaimer: www.BrusselsReport.eu will under no circumstance be held legally responsible or liable for the content of any article appearing on the website, as only the author of an article is legally responsible for that, also in accordance with the terms of use.